You can read the full letter here, but basically it's a letter from a mother in law to her daughter in law on ways to be a good daughter in law.
I've got a few comments on these:
1. Don’t tell me how I “am welcome any time” and then rant on your social media thingie about how I am “always at your house and up in your business.” If you don’t mean any time, then don’t say it. I didn’t realize I’d need to make an appointment to see my own child and grandchildren, but if that’s what it takes to keep us copacetic, then that’s what I’ll do. I fully realize that dropping by without calling first is rude, but for some reason, you never seem to answer the phone. So…
Reply: When people tell you you are welcome anytime it's kinda like when they tell you to call anytime.... They mean to use discretion. In this case, realize that we have schedules, plans, and just general stuff to do, we don't have time to entertain you while we are supposed to be cranking out all that stuff. As for why we don't answer our phone... That one is covered in another one.
2. Answer the damn phone! I am not a telemarketer trying to sell you carpet shampoo. I am the mother of your spouse, grandmother to your children, and you could at least give me the respect of picking up the phone, if only to say, “Sorry Diane, I’ve got my hands full and can’t talk right now.”
Reply: Honestly, I don't care if your the queen. When I'm up to my elbows in bleach water cleaning the floors, or reading books with my children, or stopping them from flinging their food, I do not have time to answer your phone call. And quite frankly it would be easier if you left a message or sent a text. I'm not going to interrupt a story, or bedtime to answer your phone call.
3. As much as I adore my grandchildren, I am not your free ticket to eternal childcare. Contrary to what you may think, I do have a life of my own. If you want me to watch the kids for you, I’m sure I’d probably be delighted. But you DO need to ask first with plenty of notice, so that I can rearrange my schedule if needed and stock up on groceries. If you expect me to respect your time and space, (see #1), please extend me the same courtesy. I promise to answer the phone when you call.
Reply: I don't call you often to watch my kids because quite honestly I can't trust you to follow my rules. Aside from that though, as a courtesy do not call me last minute asking if I can bring my children out to you, we have plans, schedules, and it's not fair to also ask us to drop our plans for your schedule.
4. Act like the adult you purport to be, and don’t bitch about me behind my back. I’m sure that my child doesn’t like being put in the middle any more than YOU would, so if you have a problem with me, put your big girl panties on and come talk to ME about it.
Reply: First, keep in mind that the people you complain to also repeat it to me. So don't act self righteous about it. Now let me explain something to you. Your son is now MY husband first and foremost. Andfortunately for us we have strong and open communication and that includes talking about feelings and even stuff that you've done that makes us mad. Also, our husband has asked us on countless occasions to let him handle speaking to you. Try to understand that we would like to say all of our thoughts to you ourselves..... But you would much rather hear his version.
5. Passive-aggressiveness is still aggressive.(Not to mention rude.) Don’t tell me how nice my house looks, followed immediately by some snide comment about you would rather take more time to enjoy your children instead of cleaning. You have toddlers. I don’t; I did my time. It’s a pretty simple concept. My clean house is not an automatic slam against your housekeeping skills in your own house. Defensive much?
Reply: Actually we are only commenting this way because every time you come over you make a point of doing dishes, laundry, etc, and it makes us feel bad about our housekeeping skills. We wish you understood that this is our space and to stay out of it unless asked for help. We just want you to understand that we envy your clean house, but we spend our time raising our kiddos, so don't judge ours.... And we know you judge ours because our husbands tell us that.
6. Don’t buy me clothes or decor for gifts, if they are drastically different than what I own. I hate to look a gift horse in the mouth, but I think it’s pretty clear that we shop from radically different catalogs. Gift certificates or something the kids made is perfectly acceptable and appreciated. I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but my kitchen doesn’t have a single red rooster in it, so I’m not exactly sure where you expect me to put all this barnyard memorabilia you keep buying me…
Reply: Ok cool, but if you could stop buying or clothes two sizes larger than what size I wear that would be appreciated. Or clothes that make me look fatter than I am. As you said, gift cards are perfectly acceptable.
7. It’s my money, so please let me spend it.If I want to lavish my grandchildren with gifts, it’s because I love them and I have the ability to do so. It’s not to shame you for not being able to match me dollar for dollar.
Reply: We don't actually think that your trying to shame us by spending money on our children. What makes us upset is that you don't first check if those things are appropriate for that child, if they like that, or if they are appropriate for our household. If we don't want our children playing video games and you buy them one, it going to end up on kijiji. If you give our children gun toys when we do not like them in our home, we will get rid of them. Please, consider our rules, please consider what our children want and then make your decision, this would really help.
8. I want my son/daughter to be happy and have a happy marriage, but know this: I am the mother. I will always be the mother. If by death, divorce, or desertion, you two were to ever be separated, I will still be here to pick up the pieces. Your own children will grow up one day, and you will understand this.
Reply: While you are his mother, you must also understand that I am his wife. As a husband he has to no longer put you first. He has to put his wife first. Know this: I am the wife.
9. Speaking of, you DO realize that I successfully produced an offspring that grew into such an amazing adult that YOU decided to marry and have children with…right? I may not be up on all the current parenting trends and psychological research, but by your own standards in mate selection, I must have done something right. You don’t have to hang on every word I say, and please forgive me if you think I’m overstepping with the unsolicited advice, but I have YEARS and YEARS of experience. It’s got to be good for something. Maybe you could at least try to listen to some of it every once in a while.
Reply: I married the man you raised and spent months and months fixing problems you created, problems you never bothered to address. So let me just say this. Unless I directly ask YOU for your advice, I don't want it. You had your chance to raise your children.
10. Contrary to what you might think, I am not trying to control you or judge you. Ok, well, I might judge you a little bit. I can’t help it. Really, though, I’m trying not to. I just want my son to be happy and have a good life, and I want the same for my grandchildren. Your spouse may be your spouse, but he’s still a son and a brother and an uncle and a nephew and a father, all rolled into one. You’re going to have to share, whether you like it or not. Might as well learn to be gracious about it. I had to.
Reply: Except you haven't been gracious about it, you've continually interjected into our loves about our decisions and in personal matters. You've explained to me how he is your son and that means your more important. Wrong. I don't mind sharing my husband, what I don't like is people interjecting into our lives through him. We don't need your opinion. But let me make one thing clear, I will not share if you can't learn to respect me.
XX
The Guilty Mom